Leading geneticist Steve Jones asked 'Is Human Evolution Over?' as part of the University of Edinburgh's Enlightenment Lecture Series.
Leading geneticist Steve Jones from University College of London
shook up the scientific world by claiming that evolution no longer
applies to modern homo sapiens, and that in fact, if we are to survive
for another million years, our descendents are going to look exactly
like us. His hypothesis revolves around three reasons. One, that with
the advent of modern technological ease, natural selection due to
competition has been erased. Two, since there are now fewer older
fathers, and that men tends to copulate with fewer women as compared to
earlier times, there will be less selection due to genetic mutations.
Three, random change due to population isolation is dwindling due to
better connectivity and lower inbreeding.
This theory is to some extent supported by the research conducted by University of Chicago Geneticist, Chung-I Wu. The study
shows that while DNA sequences of primates seems to be experiencing
rapid change, the sequences in the human brain remain surprisingly
static. This could be because of the brain’s immense specificity and
complexity, which leaves very little room for evolutionary tinkering,
counters Dr. Wu. He says that even a little bit of change could render a
part of the brain functionless.
There are many counter-arguments to Dr. Jones’s hypothesis, the most logical of which I found to be Dr. Hawkes’ s Weblog. Bloggers of Discover Magazine have taken it upon themselves to tear this theory down. The Guardian even published a debate about this contentious theory.
As
for me, as much merit as Dr. Jones’s theory has, I lean more towards
the second pool of opinions. To over-simplify, most people assume that
humans will either evolve towards a super-species that is capable of
incredible feats, or couch-potatoes, glued to their machines and
incapable of independent thought and action. I think either of those
theories is vastly radical. In my opinion, evolution will keep happening
– not as radically as before because of the lack of cutthroat
competition (and here, I am talking about industrialized countries –
low-income countries will face their own isolated natural selection due
to the high disease burden and extreme poverty). But overall, the very
fact that there is lower inbreeding, greater social intermingling, less
geographical division will lead to an evolution based not entirely on
genetics, but also on social and cultural factors.
FIRST
ReplyDeleteInteresting blog post. Quesetion to the writer: Since primate DNA sequences are rapidly changing, it possible that we could witness primates evolve into humans? We should discuss this over a cup of tea to clear the air.
ReplyDeleteI think that we have moved from the realm of physical evolution into mental evolution (though this can be argued to actually be physical evolution since the mind supervenes on the body)
ReplyDelete